>>297261443
Wrench is the best weapon in my opinion. Solid head hits will straight up kill all enemies and it doesn't get stuck in them like a knife or sword does. The shovel and frying pan have the best sound effects for hitting people though and being able to also stab with the shovel is fun.
As far as the guns go, the p350 I feel has the better combination of mag size and damage though the sights on the elder are really nice. As good as the 1911 is, the small mag always fucks me over at bad times. All the two handed guns feel weird in that game so I tend not to use them. MP5 still really nice though especially reloading with your new mag to slap out the old one.